IBARW

[rivkat]

Okay, so let’s take my white liberal guilt and sense of presumptuousness as read. Here are two topics I’ve been thinking about:

First, I’ve been rewatching Life on Mars, and thinking about the intersection of basic stories and racial narratives. I learned that there were only two basic stories: A stranger comes to town, and a guy gets nailed to a tree. What These People Need Is a Honky is a variant of at least one of those. In a lot of ways, therefore, Life on Mars is “What These People Need Is a Honky with Sensitivity Training,” even when Sam Tyler is just interacting with other white folks. 2007 is a better place for many individual people of color than 1973, and Sam has the privilege of believing that it’s completely different. I don’t know that I have anywhere to go with this; just something I’ve been thinking about.

Second, I haven’t seen this cross the fandom radar, but it’s of interest to me for the related intellectual property issues: Fox is promoting The Simpsons Movie by, among other things, transforming 7-11s into Qwik-E-Marts. Even the 7-11 PR spokesperson had to admit that some Indian-American franchisees were upset by being associated with Apu. Discussion by other bloggers, some of whom are unbothered, though the “they’re all stereotypes” response made me itch to get out my antiracism bingo card. When parody becomes 7-11’s corporate policy, the “it’s just entertainment” response is even less convincing. The very entertainment value of the Simpsons makes Apu a useful heuristic for people, as shown by the reports of racist use of “thank you come again” discussed at some of the above links. Of course it’s likely that the racist response would just have been different if The Simpsons didn’t exist. But it’s worth taking humor seriously.

Comments

[rivkat.livejournal.com]

And he sells questionable food and has an affair with the Slushie (or whatever it is) lady -- but of course he has admirable qualities, especially compared to Homer, along with mockable ones. It's a structural problem; because he's the representative of Asian Indian immigrants in the main cast, he bears all the weight himself. Homer gets to share with Mr. Burns, the guys at the bar, the guy who's in love with Mr. Burns, the principal, etc.

[chase820.livejournal.com]

Too bad the producers never gave his (cousin? brother?) Sanjay more of a part. Might have spread the weight around a little, at least. ;D

In all seriousness, I take your point. TV still defaults white (or in this case yellow), and even as varied a cast as The Simpsons does fall into stereotypes. But at least everybody comes off badly at times, just like everybody has redeeming qualities.

I'm surprised the gay community hasn't made more of Smithers, with his Malibu Stacy collection, and Selma, with her pro-golfer girlfriend. The portraits are affectionate, but still pretty cliched.

[chase820.livejournal.com]

Sorry, I meant Patty and her pro-golfer girlfriend. Damn that twin thing.